18 October 2004

Quarry Restoration Under Threat

The long term ability of the quarry industry to fulfil its obligations and commitments to quarry restoration is being increasingly threatened by waves of uncoordinated regulation that is inhibiting the use of inert waste as fill.

Operators say that the combined effects of the Landfill Directive, the Waste Framework Directive and new waste licensing regulations means that quarries that have historically relied on imported inert construction and demolition wastes are now facing major barriers in returning land for beneficial after uses. They also fear that current high levels of recovery of waste for use as recycled aggregates will be inhibited as a result of confusing new regulations that are currently at odds with each other and place major additional burdens on sites handling such materials. Of particular concern is the fact that the Landfill Regulations (2002) apply costly Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) requirements to inert landfills even when those sites deal with materials that pose no pollution risk.

"While we enthusiastically support the trend towards recycled aggregates, our members have, as a result, lost significant volume of inert material for restoration, " says QPA Planning Executive, Nienke Veldkamp. "Our members do not wish to use those inert materials that can be recycled for restoration purposes; however, they can ill afford to lose what cannot otherwise be recycled because of overly restrictive regulations".

"A steady and adequate supply of aggregates is vital to the delivery of many of the Governmental initiatives, particularly the Sustainable Communities Plan spearheaded by the Deputy Prime Minister, John Prescott", says QPA Chief Executive, Simon van der Byl. "Although it is QPA policy that secondary and recycled aggregates should form the first element of supply, these materials cannot meet the total demand, both in quality and more significantly in sufficient quantity. As such the continued extraction of primary aggregates is essential to meet the needs of society currently and in the future. The use of inert waste for restoration of mineral workings is a vital part of the sustainable aggregates supply chain and needs to be recognised as such. Yet it is being increasingly threatened by the cumulative effects of overly restrictive regulations and inappropriate guidance.

"Given their shallow nature and the fact that many are below the water table, it is the restoration of sand and gravel sites – for which the industry has a world-class record – that are most in need of imported inert wastes.

The QPA are seeking discussions on the problem with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and the Environment Agency, which are between them faced with interpreting the latest raft of European regulation. In its position statement, the QPA have come up with five key recommendations:

* Infilling and restoration of mineral workings should be regarded as a re-use or recovery of waste in accordance with European legislation

* A specific exemption from waste management licensing should be applied to the use of inert waste for restoration of active quarry workings

* Landfill regulations should be amended to remove inert wastes from the IPPC regime

* Guidance to identify products and residues generated by crushing and screening of construction wastes as inert

* Guidance to ensure that the regulatory burden does not exceed the intentions of the legislation concerned.

ENDS

Notes to editors

1. The Quarry Products Association is the principal trade association representing the UK aggregates industry. In England, its members produce over 90 per cent of aggregates extracted – sand and gravel and crushed rock as well as other non-aggregate minerals such as silica sand, agricultural and industrial lime including limestone, chalk, clay and shale for cement.
2. For a full copy of the QPA’s position document "The Use of Inert Wastes for the Restoration of Aggregate Mineral Workings", please contact Nienke Veldkamp.

If you need any more information, please contact our Press Office.